“He came on a November day, a cold wind blowing, the fields soaked with rain.”
With this first sentence, the first paragraph, the first page, then the second page , I knew I was starting a book I would enjoy
Apart from Galileo’s Daughter by Dava Sobel I haven’t found much to interest me in period stories set in Italy, such as Medici stories. But this rather tragic tale is unforgettable.
I hadn’t heard of it until one night recently it was discussed on the Book Show on Australian ABC TV and now having read the book I went back and watched their comments again more carefully. To them it seemed the love story was secondary to the Gothic, the darkness, the evil, the religion and politics. But I’m a people person and the meeting and the gradual involvement of the sculptor and the beautiful young girl was what it was all about. . It is set in the less affluent parts of Florence and the countryside with the brief ventures of the sculptor into princely circles.
Because it was set in late C17th Italy how a relationship developed depended on the laws and the morals of the time., and this historical background floats along underneath the characters of the story. There are also some fine descriptions of how sculpture in wax was done in those times and some unforgettable minor characters along the way.
Then there are the secrets. We all have our little secrets which we don’t reveal to casual acquaintances. And it is these secrets held by different characters in the book which lead the story to its conclusion.
It wasn’t until I had finished the book that I found out that Zumbo was a real person who spent his life fleeing foom his home in Sicily. He really did make the wax sculptures depicting the plague. This has made the book even more fascinating in retrospect.
The boy-girl story and the secrets were but the dominant factors of the book to me. I enjoyed the background, it was a necessary part of the story, but it wasn’t the story itself.
But, I found a different interpretation of the book in the Australian ABC TV’s Book Club. For the discussion the three regulars were joined by authors Junot Diaz and Sarah Dunant. I don’t think I’ve read anything by either of them but after listening to them talk I certainly intend to remedy that.
The background seemed to be everything to them -evil, hell-hole, darkness, gothic, pious, sordid were some of the words they used. True, but what did they expect in C17th Florence and was it very different to what is happening in different parts of our world and which we read in our papers and hear on the TV news each night.
I don’t think the panel made any mention of the title, Secrecy, which is such an important part of the story. As secrets are revealed so are actions determined. Knowledge determines how we react to a situation.
Soo…we all liked the book, but with different interpretations and for different reasons. My appreciation of the book was enriched by listening to these two discussions, the first from the ABC Book Club and the second from an interview with the author Rupert Thomson.